Reference.com

What's Your Question?

  • History & Geography
  • Science & Technology
  • Business & Finance
  • Pets & Animals

What Is the Thesis of “Once More to the Lake” by E.B. White?

“Once More to the Lake” is an essay by E.B. White describing his emotions when he returns to a childhood summer place. He had first visited the Maine camp with his own father in 1904, and he revisits in 1941 with his son. He compares the lake of his memory with the largely unchanged contemporary scene and simultaneously experiences the place through his son’s eyes and his own.

White’s essay follows the trail of memory as he and his son drive to the cabin and unload their gear, rent a motorized boat for bass fishing and dine at a local restaurant. White begins to feel as though he is the son listening to his father’s words coming out of his own mouth. He imagines that time has stood still and that a dragonfly, the bather with a bar of soap and teenagers in a steamship cruise boat are the same ones he had noticed as a child.

The essay is an exercise in duality. Is White the son or the father? Has time passed or is it frozen? It ends with White feeling the “chill of death” as he watches his son pull a soggy, cold bathing suit up around “his vitals,” a reference to his own mortality.

MORE FROM REFERENCE.COM

thesis for once more to the lake

Panmore Institute

  • About / Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Alphabetical List of Companies
  • Business Analysis Topics

Analysis of E. B. White’s “Once More to the Lake”

An analysis of E.B. White essay Once More to the Lake

E.B. White’s essay, Once More to the Lake , which was first published in 1941, describes his experience as he revisits a childhood lake in Maine. This revisiting is a journey in which White delights in memories associated with his childhood and the lake. In effect, his mindset transforms and goes back to his childhood. This transformation is necessary for him to find enjoyment in the journey. However, the transformation also emphasizes an altered perception of the actual lake. For instance, instead of viewing the lake as it is, he uses his childhood eyes to perceive the lake. This condition creates an interesting departure from reality into what he wants to see based on his childhood experiences. Once More to the Lake is a depiction of E. B. White’s experience as he visits a lake once again – the lake that he has been fond of since childhood.

E. B. White’s experience brings him to the lakefront, where he finds himself staring at the same lake, which is virtually unchanged. This means that White focuses on the unchanging things despite the surrounding changes and the changes that he experiences in his life. White wants to emphasize the permanence of some things, or at least the permanence of the memory of those things, despite the never-ending change that happens in the world.

Even though the lake itself has not changed, E. B. White’s essay indicates that there are some changes in things that are separate from the lake. For example, when White arrives at the lakefront, he wishes to enjoy the scene and the experience of being at the lake once again, but he becomes bothered by the noise of the new boats that are on the lake. The new boats have noisier engines.

E. B. White wants to show that technology can be disruptive. Technology can, indeed, make things become faster and more efficient, but it can also make things noisier, more disruptive, or undesirable. Thus, White emphasizes the negative side of new technologies. Nonetheless, as White continues his story, it is indicated that he has a liking for old engines. This liking started from his childhood. Even though he first views technology as something disruptive, the essay also touches on personal perception and preference. For instance, White does not like the new engines and the noise they make. However, this dislike could be due to his desire and expectation to see boats with the old engines that he saw in his childhood.

Some things may not change. All things change based on the underlying principle that nothing is constant in this world and that every little thing changes. However, there are some things that may not change, such as the thought of a person, the feelings that one has toward other people, and the longing for something. E.B. White shows that the lake is unchanged, but this may be only in his own perception. It is possible that the lake has already changed when he arrives as an adult at the lakefront, but his perception of the lake does not change. This perception and the associated emotions do not change, as he still likes what he sees and feels.

His experience of being at the lakefront brings him back to his childhood years when he was a boy experiencing the lake. Considering that White shows that his perception switches between that of an adult and that of a boy, it is arguable that his actual experience of the lake as an adult is marred by such switching between perceptions. It is possible that the actual lake that he revisits is already different, but his perception, as a boy, does not change, thereby making the lake only virtually unchanged. Also, the technology that he refers to, in the form of new and noisier engines, may have also been affected by such switching in his perceptions. It is possible that the new and noisier boats are not really that disruptive. It is just that he is used to the old and less noisy ones, thereby making his claims about the new boats personally subjective and not necessarily real.

E.B. White’s lake is a symbol of the role of physical spaces in personal development. For example, the essay shows that the lake serves as a setting for familial interactions, especially in the author’s past. Also, the lake serves as a venue for reflection. When White goes back to the lake, it facilitates his reflection of change and development. The lake helps him think back and develop a better understanding of his situation.

E.B. White’s essay, Once More to the Lake , supports the idea of the necessity of permanence in life. Even though the lake has changed over the years, it remains a lake that the author can visit. His current visit to the lake also represents his desire to be there. The lake stands as a reminder of his childhood experiences. In this regard, the lake sheds light on the benefit of having some form or degree of permanence in life. This permanence can help anchor the person and his psychological development.

  • White, E. B. (1941). Once More to the Lake .
  • White, E. B. (2016). Essays of E. B. White . Perennial.
  • Copyright by Panmore Institute - All rights reserved.
  • This article may not be reproduced, distributed, or mirrored without written permission from Panmore Institute and its author/s.
  • Educators, Researchers, and Students: You are permitted to quote or paraphrase parts of this article (not the entire article) for educational or research purposes, as long as the article is properly cited and referenced together with its URL/link.

Once More to the Lake Summary & Analysis

Summary of once more to the lake by e.b. white, once more to the lake | summary.

“Once More to the Lake” is an autobiographical essay written by E.B. White. The essay revolves around White’s visit to a lake in Maine, where he used to vacation as a child, with his own son. White reflects upon the passage of time and the changes that have occurred since his childhood.

As White revisits the lake, he finds himself experiencing a sense of déjà vu, as the surroundings and activities mirror those of his own youth. He vividly describes the sights, sounds, and smells of the lake, evoking a strong sense of nostalgia. White observes his son engaging in activities that he himself once enjoyed, blurring the lines between past and present.

Throughout the essay, White contemplates the notion of time and its impact on both the physical environment and human existence. He comes to the realization that although the lake itself remains relatively unchanged, he has grown older and is now confronted with his own mortality. This recognition of the universal cycle of life and the passage of time brings forth a profound and somber reflection on the nature of existence.

Once More to the Lake | Analysis

The essay’s personal and autobiographical nature is evidenced by its use of concrete and specific language. This language establishes the essay’s adherence to Huxley’s criteria for excellence, particularly in terms of presenting objective facts and focusing on tangible details. Ultimately, White’s contemplation of these specific details, both remembered and freshly observed, leads him to a profound realization that transcends the individual experience and embraces a universal truth.

Once More to the Lake | Themes

Once more to the lake | literary devices, summary & analysis of greasy lake, the great lawsuit summary, related articles, miss awful summary, analysis & themes, 2br02b | summary and analysis, transforming moments | summary and analysis, poetry is not a luxury summary & analysis, leave a reply cancel reply, adblock detected.

E.B. White's Drafts of 'Once More to the Lake'

"I returned to Belgrade. Things haven't changed much."

New York Times Co. / Getty Images

  • An Introduction to Punctuation
  • Ph.D., Rhetoric and English, University of Georgia
  • M.A., Modern English and American Literature, University of Leicester
  • B.A., English, State University of New York

At the start of every fall term, countless students are asked to write an essay on what must be the most uninspired composition topic of all time: "How I Spent My Summer Vacation." Still, it's remarkable what a good writer can do with such a seemingly dull subject--though it may take a bit longer than usual to complete the assignment.

In this case, the good writer was E.B. White , and the essay that took more than a quarter century to complete was "Once More to the Lake."

First Draft: Pamphlet on Belgrade Lake (1914)

Back in 1914, shortly before his 15th birthday, Elwyn White responded to this familiar topic with uncommon enthusiasm. It was a subject the boy knew well and an experience that he fiercely enjoyed. Every August for the past decade, White's father had taken the family to the same camp on Belgrade Lake in Maine. In a self-designed pamphlet, complete with sketches and photos, young Elwyn began his report clearly and conventionally

This wonderful lake is five miles wide, and about ten miles long, with many coves, points and islands. It is one of a series of lakes, which are connected with each other by little streams. One of these streams is several miles long and deep enough so that it affords an opportunity for a fine all-day canoe trip. . . . The lake is large enough to make the conditions ideal for all kinds of small boats. The bathing also is a feature, for the days grow very warm at noon time and make a good swim feel fine. (reprinted in Scott Elledge, ​ E.B. White: A Biography. Norton, 1984)

Second Draft: Letter to Stanley Hart White (1936)

In the summer of 1936, E. B. White, by then a popular writer for The New Yorker magazine, made a return visit to this childhood vacation spot. While there, he wrote a long letter to his brother Stanley, vividly describing the sights, sounds, and smells of the lake. Here are a few excerpts:

The lake hangs clear and still at dawn, and the sound of a cowbell comes softly from a faraway woodlot. In the shallows along shore the pebbles and driftwood show clear and smooth on bottom, and black water bugs dart, spreading a wake and a shadow. A fish rises quickly in the lily pads with a little plop, and a broad ring widens to eternity. The water in the basin is icy before breakfast, and cuts sharply into your nose and ears and makes your face blue as you wash. But the boards of the dock are already hot in the sun, and there are doughnuts for breakfast and the smell is there, the faintly rancid smell that hangs around Maine kitchens. Sometimes there is little wind all day, and on still hot afternoons the sound of a motorboat comes drifting five miles from the other shore, and the droning lake becomes articulate, like a hot field. A crow calls, fearfully and far. If a night breeze springs up, you are aware of a restless noise along the shore, and for a few minutes before you fall asleep you hear the intimate talk between fresh-water waves and rocks that lie below bending birches. The insides of your camp are hung with pictures cut from magazines, and the camp smells of lumber and damp. Things don't change much. . . . ( Letters of E.B. White , edited by Dorothy Lobrano Guth. Harper & Row, 1976)

Final Revision: "Once More to the Lake" (1941)

White made the return journey in 1936 on his own, in part to commemorate his parents, both of whom had recently died. When he next made the trip to Belgrade Lake, in 1941, he took along his son Joel. White recorded that experience in what has become one of the best-known and most frequently anthologized essays of the past century, "Once More to the Lake":

We went fishing the first morning. I felt the same damp moss covering the worms in the bait can, and saw the dragonfly alight on the tip of my rod as it hovered a few inches from the surface of the water. It was the arrival of this fly that convinced me beyond any doubt that everything was as it always had been, that the years were a mirage and there had been no years. The small waves were the same, chucking the rowboat under the chin as we fished at anchor, and the boat was the same boat, the same color green and the ribs broken in the same places, and under the floor-boards the same fresh-water leavings and debris--the dead hellgrammite, the wisps of moss, the rusty discarded fishhook, the dried blood from yesterday's catch. We stared silently at the tips of our rods, at the dragonflies that came and went. I lowered the tip of mine into the water, pensively dislodging the fly, which darted two feet away, poised, darted two feet back, and came to rest again a little farther up the rod. There had been no years between the ducking of this dragonfly and the other one--the one that was part of memory. . . . (Harper's, 1941; reprinted in One Man's Meat . Tilbury House Publishers, 1997)

Certain details from White's 1936 letter reappear in his 1941 essay: damp moss, birch beer, the smell of lumber, the sound of outboard motors. In his letter, White insisted that "things don't change much," and in his essay, we hear the refrain, "There had been no years." But in both texts, we sense that the author was working hard to sustain an illusion. A joke may be "deathless," the lake may be "fade-proof," and summer may seem to be "without end." Yet as White makes clear in the concluding image of "Once More to the Lake," only the pattern of life is "indelible":

When the others went swimming my son said he was going in too. He pulled his dripping trunks from the line where they had hung all through the shower, and wrung them out. Languidly, and with no thought of going in, I watched him, his hard little body, skinny and bare, saw him wince slightly as he pulled up around his vitals the small, soggy, icy garment. As he buckled the swollen belt, suddenly my groin felt the chill of death.

To spend almost 30 years composing an essay is exceptional. But then, you have to admit, so is "Once More to the Lake."

Postscript (1981)

According to Scott Elledge in E.B. White: A Biography , on July 11, 1981, to celebrate his eighty-first birthday, White lashed a canoe to the top of his car and drove to "the same Belgrade lake where, seventy years before, he had received a green old town canoe from his father, a gift for his eleventh birthday."

  • Reading Quiz on 'Once More to the Lake' by E. B. White
  • What E.B. White Has to Say About Writing
  • What Is a Past Progressive Verb in English?
  • What Is a Personal Essay (Personal Statement)?
  • What Is Imagery (In Language)?
  • What Is Reflected Meaning?
  • Definition and Examples of Vignettes in Prose
  • Practice in Identifying Metaphors
  • E.B. White's Diction and Metaphors in 'Death of a Pig'
  • First-Person Point of View
  • What is Identification in Rhetoric?
  • Everyday vs. Every Day: How to Choose the Right Word
  • Postscript (P.S.) Definition and Examples in Writing
  • Imply vs. Infer: How to Choose the Right Word
  • Tetracolon Climax (Rhetoric and Sentence Styles)
  • 100 Major Works of Modern Creative Nonfiction
  • Divisions and Offices
  • Grants Search
  • Manage Your Award
  • NEH's Application Review Process
  • Professional Development
  • Grantee Communications Toolkit
  • NEH Virtual Grant Workshops
  • Awards & Honors
  • American Tapestry
  • Humanities Magazine
  • NEH Resources for Native Communities
  • Search Our Work
  • Office of Communications
  • Office of Congressional Affairs
  • Office of Data and Evaluation
  • Budget / Performance
  • Contact NEH
  • Equal Employment Opportunity
  • Human Resources
  • Information Quality
  • National Council on the Humanities
  • Office of the Inspector General
  • Privacy Program
  • State and Jurisdictional Humanities Councils
  • Office of the Chair
  • NEH-DOI Federal Indian Boarding School Initiative Partnership
  • NEH Equity Action Plan
  • GovDelivery

E. B. White’s Song of Summer

Timeless and poignant, "once more to the lake" still speaks to the passing of life's seasons..

Labor Day, the unofficial close of summer, is a good time to remember E. B. White, whose elegant good-bye to the season still draws readers 75 years after its publication.

White memorialized summer in “Once More to the Lake,” a 1941 meditation on the passage of time that has become among the most widely anthologized essays in the English language. Elwyn Brooks White (1899–1985)—Andy to his friends—is best known as the author of  Charlotte’s Web  and  Stuart Little , children’s books inspired by his later years on a saltwater farm in Maine. White had lived in Manhattan, thriving as a writer for the  New Yorker , but he had a midlife crisis of sorts shortly before World War II. Seeking a change in how he lived and wrote, he moved to Maine with his wife, Katharine, the  New Yorker ’s fiction editor, a transition chronicled in a 2014  Humanities article . The children’s books that grew from that experience are justly celebrated. But White also published sublimely expressed essays about his life as a father, farmer, and husband, of which “Once More to the Lake” is perhaps the most famous.

The premise is simple, or at least appears to be. “One summer, along about 1904,” he tells readers, “my father rented a camp on a lake in Maine and took us all there for the month of August . . . the vacation was a success, and from then on none of us ever thought there was any place in the world like that lake in Maine. We returned summer after summer—always on August 1st for one month.”  

In the summer of 1941, as he turned 42, White returned to the same lake with his son, wondering if the magic could be repeated. He finds that despite the decades, much remains the same. But in recounting his experiences, White strikes a tone of elegy, as if his lake adventure is already receding into memory. His piece, which was published by  Harper’s  in August 1941, just as the season was drawing to a close, describes his Maine world:

Summertime, oh summertime, pattern of life indelible, the fade-proof lake, the woods unshatterable, the pasture with the sweetfern and the juniper forever and ever, summer without end; this was the background, and life along the shore was the design, the cottages with their infinite and tranquil design, their tiny docks with the flagpole and the American flag floating against the white clouds in the blue sky . . . and at the souvenir counters at the store the miniature birch-bark canoes and the post cards showing things looking a little better than they looked.

The last line of the passage is vintage White. He begins on a breath of nostalgia, but then he resists the urge to see things as we wish them to be, insisting that they instead be seen as they are.

That tension rests at the heart of White’s reflection on his return to the lake with his son. For much of the essay, living vicariously through his son, he tricks himself into thinking that he  is  his son, a grown man restored to boyhood. Without quite saying so—White had a genius for showing rather than telling—he hints that this confusion of identity is a symptom of our middle years, that period of life in which we often feel mentally as if we’re one age, although chronologically we’re another.

But in the final paragraph, as his son slips on some wet swim trunks, a flash of recognition returns White to reality. “As he buckled the swollen belt,” White tells readers, “suddenly my groin felt the chill of death.”

Although White usefully avoided adorning his essays with teachable moments, at least one lesson of “Once More to the Lake” is obvious. Our supply of summers is not infinite, which is why each one is worth savoring.

In 1951, when an apparently young reader named Marilyn Boyer wrote White to ask him what “Once More to the Lake” was about, White mentioned its autumnal theme of mortality.

“At your age this is perhaps hard to understand,” he told her. “It will become clearer to you later on. Meantime, be thankful that a wet bathing suit is just a wet bathing suit.”

Sources:  One Man’s Meat  by E. B. White,  Letters of E. B. White , revised edition.

Danny Heitman is the editor of Phi Kappa Phi’s Forum magazine and a columnist for the  Advocate newspaper in Louisiana. He writes frequently about arts and culture for national publications, including the Wall Street Journal and the  Christian Science Monitor.

Funding information

NEH has supported numerous projects relating to children’s literature and writers connected to the  New Yorker , including James Thurber, E. B. White, and A. J. Liebling. Some of White’s essays have been collected in thematic volumes published by  Library of America , which was started with the help of a major grant from NEH. White also appears, along with many other writers, in the correspondence files of Morris Leopold Ernst, a lawyer who cofounded the ACLU and whose papers are being curated with NEH support at the  Harry Ransom Center at the University of Texas at Austin .

Photo of man in boat supervising swimming children

SUBSCRIBE FOR HUMANITIES MAGAZINE PRINT EDITION Browse all issues   Sign up for HUMANITIES Magazine newsletter

HCCS Learning Web

  • Houston Community College
  • Eagle Online

HCCS Learning Web

  • Brent Baggaley
  • Composition IIa Spring 2017 (ENGL 1302)
  • Readings and Links

Once More to the Lake

To print or download this file, click the link below:

PDF document icon

Once More to the Lake

Once more to the lake lyrics.

How to Format Lyrics:

  • Type out all lyrics, even repeating song parts like the chorus
  • Lyrics should be broken down into individual lines
  • Use section headers above different song parts like [Verse], [Chorus], etc.
  • Use italics ( <i>lyric</i> ) and bold ( <b>lyric</b> ) to distinguish between different vocalists in the same song part
  • If you don’t understand a lyric, use [?]

To learn more, check out our transcription guide or visit our transcribers forum

First published in Harper’s magazine in 1941, “Once More to the Lake” narrates White’s visit to Belgrade Lakes, Maine, where he had vacationed as a child.

thesis for once more to the lake

Golden Pond in Belgrade Lakes. Image via Maine Travel Maven.

For a fresh look at White’s timeless children’s novel, Charlotte’s Web , read the Lit Genius original, “Hidden Threads: Revisiting "Charlotte’s Web”.

Find answers to frequently asked questions about the song and explore its deeper meaning

Genius is the world’s biggest collection of song lyrics and musical knowledge

thesis for once more to the lake

Advertisement

Rare catch in lake erie called a ‘unicorn,’ and a fish of a lifetime, share this article.

A teen fishing in a walleye/steelhead tournament thought he had hooked a big steelhead, but once the fish was boated, he quickly realized it was a salmon species that was out of place in Lake Erie. It was an Atlantic salmon.

Colton Alex, an experienced fisherman at age 18, was fishing in the tournament with Capt. Joe Nemet of Nemesis Sport Fishing when the fish hit a spoon 65 feet down, according to GoErie .

“It fought like a bigger steelhead,” Alex told GoErie. “Once it was netted, as soon as I felt the jaw, saw the jaw, I thought ‘OK, this is a coho [salmon],’ but as soon as I saw the spots, I was like, ‘Oh my gosh, this is an Atlantic salmon.’

“This is probably the rarest catch I’ve had on Lake Erie. Definitely, it’s kind of a unicorn of a fish for sure…

“I’ve caught my fair share of salmon. I caught Atlantics in Ontario, but I never caught one in Erie or even seen one being caught, and it was by far the biggest one I even heard of being caught.”

The fish measured 30 inches and weighed 10.4 pounds.

thesis for once more to the lake

“It was the biggest Atlantic salmon I’ve ever seen,” Nemet (above, holding fish) told GoErie. “If you were going to tell me I was going to catch a 10.4-pound Atlantic salmon, I would tell you it was probably going to be on Lake Ontario, not Lake Erie.”

Mark Haffley, a biologist for the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission, told GoErie that Atlantic salmon are rare in Lake Erie and that they’ve seen some each year caught in the tributary fishery. He added that “they are being stocked in the southern tip of Lake Huron and that is more than likely how they are getting here.”

Catches of Atlantic salmon in Erie will continue to be uncommon, Haffley said.

“Getting salmon here is uncommon and getting an Atlantic [salmon] here is even more uncommon,” Nemet told GoErie. “It’s definitely a fish of a lifetime.”

Photos of Colton Alex and Joe Nemet holding the fish courtesy of Alex. 

Most Popular

The french pole vaulter who hit his crotch on the bar made the perfect tiktok in response, 6 astonishing photos of the usa women's 4x400 relay looking like they were alone on the track while winning gold, ranking the 10 finest nfl linebackers of all time, the tiktok 'just give me my money' trend that's gone viral, explained, 12 incredible olympics rhythmic gymnastics photos that will make your body ache, team france roster: meet the basketball host nation with a chance to medal at the 2024 paris olympics, do not draft: 11 nfl busts (cooper kupp) in 2024 you should avoid picking entirely in fantasy football.

Please enter an email address.

Thanks for signing up.

Please check your email for a confirmation.

Something went wrong.

Serbian CrossFit competitor Lazar Dukic dies during Texas lake swimming event

CrossFit chief executive Don Faul says organisers are "deeply saddened" by the death and are working with authorities on the subsequent investigation.

Thursday 8 August 2024 23:25, UK

thesis for once more to the lake

A CrossFit Games competitor has died while taking part in a swimming event.

Lazar Dukic was competing at Marine Creek Lake in Fort Worth, Texas, on Thursday morning when he disappeared beneath the water.

Emergency services were called at around 8am local time to reports there "was a participant in the water that was down and hadn't been seen in some point in time".

Our deepest condolences to Lazar Đukić’s family and all those who knew and loved him. pic.twitter.com/8uvhzvTD2v — Rogue Fitness (@RogueFitness) August 8, 2024

After launching a search with a dive team and drones, the athlete's body was found around an hour after the first divers went into the water.

thesis for once more to the lake

The rest of the events on day one of the games were cancelled after the death.

CrossFit chief executive Don Faul said in a news conference the organisers were "deeply saddened" by the death and were working with authorities on the subsequent investigation.

He added: "We're doing everything in our power during this tragic time to support the family, to support our community."

Don Faul, CrossFit chief executive. Pic: AP

Mr Faul also confirmed CrossFit did have safety personnel on site during the swim.

Read more from Sky News: US sprinter with COVID leaves track in wheelchair Ballerina facing up to 15 years in Russian jail Sky News nominated for International Emmy

Follow Sky News on WhatsApp

Keep up with all the latest news from the UK and around the world by following Sky News

The medical examiner's office has not yet listed the cause of Dukic's death.

Dukic's biography on the CrossFit website says he was the third ranked CrossFit athlete in Serbia and the 88th ranked worldwide.

pic.twitter.com/vFO8iTK8XQ — The CrossFit Games (@CrossFitGames) August 8, 2024

Be the first to get Breaking News

Install the Sky News app for free

thesis for once more to the lake

CrossFit is a branded fitness regime that involves competing in a variety of movements at a high intensity.

CrossFit has been approached for comment.

Related Topics

Once More to the Lake

Guide cover image

16 pages • 32 minutes read

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Essay Analysis

Key Figures

Symbols & Motifs

Literary Devices

Important Quotes

Essay Topics

Discussion Questions

Personification

White persistently describes his surroundings in human terms in order to better describe them. An example occurs in the essay’s first paragraph, when White describes “the restlessness of the tide” (1) to emphasize the lake’s relaxing elements in contrast to the ocean’s volatility. Another example of personification appears when White notes the noise of the outboard motors and the “petulant, irritable” noises they make. These descriptions contrast with the old two-cylinder motors, which “purred and purred” (4), and the one-cylinder motors that “[eat] out of your hand if you got really close to it spiritually” (4). By describing these old motors as if they are obedient domestic pets, they heighten the irritation caused by the outboard motors, which are described as if they were bothersome children.

Metaphor/Simile

blurred text

Related Titles

By E. B. White

Charlotte's Web

Guide cover image

Here Is New York

Guide cover image

Stuart Little

Guide cover image

The Trumpet of the Swan

Guide cover image

Featured Collections

View Collection

Essays & Speeches

Mortality & Death

Election Highlights: Trump Takes Stage in Montana After Harris and Walz Rally in Arizona

After the new Democratic ticket made its appeal in the battleground border state, the former president is stumping for the Republican challenging Senator Jon Tester.

  • Share full article

thesis for once more to the lake

Michael Gold and Simon J. Levien

Reporting from Bozeman, Mont.

Fine-tuning his attacks on Harris, Trump tries using her words against her.

As former President Donald J. Trump continues to reach for attacks on his new opponent, Vice President Kamala Harris, that might halt her political momentum, he unveiled a new tactic at a rally in Bozeman, Mont., on Friday night, aiming to use Ms. Harris’s own words against her.

Interrupting his typical pattern of a digressive and lengthy speech, Mr. Trump played two video compilations of past remarks by Ms. Harris that his campaign hopes will portray her as overly liberal and inept.

The first video drew on statements that Ms. Harris made during the 2020 presidential campaign, when she tacked to the left and backed progressive ideas on criminal justice reform. The second was a montage of interviews and speeches that Mr. Trump’s campaign used to mock her speaking style and insult her intelligence.

The videos did little to alter the message that the Trump campaign has deployed against Ms. Harris for weeks and that Mr. Trump summed up during his speech on Friday.

“America cannot survive for four more years of this bumbling communist lunatic,” Mr. Trump told thousands gathered in the Brick Breeden Fieldhouse at Montana State University. “We cannot let her win this election.”

Mr. Trump and his allies have repeatedly tried to portray Ms. Harris as more liberal than President Biden in the three weeks since he ended his campaign and cleared the way for her to be the Democratic presidential nominee.

The video compiling her past positions accused her of supporting a ban on fracking, mandatory gun buybacks and a single-payer health insurance system like “Medicare for all.”

Ms. Harris has backed away from those policy positions, which largely stem from her time in the 2020 presidential race. But Mr. Trump — who has been known to flip-flop or equivocate on hot-button issues like abortion — argued that her early statements were the only ones that mattered.

Mr. Trump’s rally on Friday was his first since Ms. Harris chose Gov. Tim Walz of Minnesota as her running mate, and he used the selection to bolster his portrait of the Democratic ticket as overly liberal. Effectively likening Mr. Walz to a socialist, he accused the governor of being too lax in his response to protests that turned to riots in Minneapolis after the police murder of George Floyd and for signing a law giving access to menstrual products to transgender children.

Referring to Mr. Walz as “Comrade Walz,” Mr. Trump argued that Ms. Harris tapped him for his progressive bona fides. “This is her ideology,” he said.

Mr. Trump also acknowledged that he has frequently mispronounced Ms. Harris’s given name in recent speeches, though he added that he “couldn’t care less” how it should be pronounced. He admitted that he has in the past “done a lot of bad name-calling” in which he has purposefully mispronounced a person’s name. “They say, ‘Sir, you made a mistake,’” Mr. Trump recounted. “I said, ‘No, I didn’t.’”

Still, Mr. Trump’s speech offered continued evidence of the growing pains he has faced as he tries to shift years of attacks against Mr. Biden toward Ms. Harris.

Even as he argued that Ms. Harris was more extreme than Mr. Biden, he tied her to the president’s policies on immigration and the economy.

At one point, he said she was the one running the country the past four years, even as he repeatedly argued that she was too unintelligent or incompetent to do so effectively. Mr. Trump has long made the same argument about Mr. Biden.

Mr. Trump's rally is part of a western swing that includes fund-raisers in mountain resort towns favored by the wealthy. Before he took the stage in Bozeman, he attended an event in Big Sky, Mont., and on Saturday he will travel to fund-raisers in Jackson Hole, Wyo., and Aspen, Colo.

Montana is not an obvious site for a presidential campaign rally. Mr. Trump won the state handily in both 2016 and 2020, and he is expected to do so again in November. But with Republicans keen on flipping Democrats’ narrow edge in the Senate, Mr. Trump traveled to Montana to support his party’s Senate candidate there, Tim Sheehy, who is looking to unseat the Democratic incumbent, Senator Jon Tester.

At one point, Mr. Trump, whose flight to Bozeman was diverted to another city after his plane suffered a mechanical issue, reflected on how long it takes to travel to Montana.

“I’ve got to like Tim Sheehy a lot to be here,” he said.

thesis for once more to the lake

Shawn Hubler Maggie Haberman and Heather Knight

Yes, Trump was in a scary helicopter ride, but not with that politician.

Donald J. Trump was doubling down on Friday about his story of nearly crashing during a helicopter ride once with Willie Brown, the notable Black California politician.

He was so adamant that it had happened that he threatened to sue The New York Times for reporting that the story was untrue , then posted on his social media site that there were “‘Logs,’ Maintenance Records, and Witnesses” to back up his account.

“It was Willie Brown,” Mr. Trump, who spent much of the last year hoping to make gains with Black voters, posted. “But now Willie doesn’t remember?”

Mr. Brown, 90, who was mayor of San Francisco and speaker of the California Assembly, gave several interviews on Thursday and Friday saying such a trip never occurred.

Turns out, however, that there was a Black politician from California who once made an emergency landing in a helicopter with Mr. Trump. It just wasn’t Mr. Brown.

Nate Holden, 95, a former Los Angeles city councilman and state senator, said in an interview with The Times that he had been on a helicopter ride with Mr. Trump around 1990 when the aircraft experienced mechanical trouble and was forced to make an emergency landing in New Jersey.

Recounting an episode that he had described earlier on Friday to Politico, Mr. Holden said Mr. Trump had been seeking to develop the site of the Ambassador Hotel in Los Angeles when it was part of Mr. Holden’s district. Mr. Trump wanted him to see his Taj Mahal casino, Mr. Holden said, so on a visit to Manhattan, he rode with Mr. Trump from his Midtown skyscraper to a helipad, where the two took off for Atlantic City, accompanied by Mr. Trump’s brother Robert and by his executive vice president of construction and development, Barbara Res.

“He was trying to impress me,” Mr. Holden said. “We start flying to New Jersey. He said, ‘Look at the skyline! Look at how beautiful it is! And I’m part of it!’”

Mr. Holden said he wasn’t impressed. “I grew up in New Jersey,” he said. “It ain’t nothing new to me.”

“Anyway,” he continued, “we start flying to Atlantic City. He’s talking about how great things are. And about 15, 20 minutes in, the pilot yells, ‘Shut up! Shut up!’”

The hydraulic system had failed, he said. “Donald turned white as snow,” Mr. Holden recalled. “He was shaking.”

Mr. Holden said that as the helicopter’s crew worked frantically to set the aircraft down safely, his own thoughts ran to a helicopter crash in 1989 that had killed three senior executives of Mr. Trump’s casinos over Forked River, N.J.

“I just thought, how the hell do you let your staff not maintain your aircraft after you just had a crash that killed some of your staff? How could you let this happen again? I thought, if we go down, this is your fault.”

The helicopter ultimately landed safely in Linden, N.J., Mr. Holden said.

Ms. Res wrote about the episode in a memoir and corroborated Mr. Holden’s account in a brief interview late Friday. Ms. Res, who also spoke to Politico, recalled that Mr. Trump liked to say that Mr. Holden had “turned white” from fear, but that it was actually Mr. Trump whose face was ashen.

A spokesman for Mr. Trump did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment.

Mr. Holden said he was in his living room watching Mr. Trump’s news conference on TV on Thursday when the former president told of experiencing a brush with death on a helicopter ride with Mr. Brown.

“I said, ‘What the hell is this?’” Mr. Holden said. “‘Was he in two near-fatal helicopter crashes? He didn’t fix those damn helicopters yet?’”

Mr. Holden said that he called Mr. Brown to compare notes. Mr. Brown told him he had never been in a helicopter with Mr. Trump.

“I said, ‘Willie, you know what? That’s me!’” Mr. Holden said. “And I told him, ‘You’re a short Black guy and I’m a tall Black guy — but we all look alike, right?’”

Mr. Holden gave his own height as 6-foot-1. “Willie has to be about 5-foot-6. Maybe 5-foot-5. He comes up to about my shoulders. And he’s bald. And I’m not bald.”

Mr. Brown, he said, “just laughed and laughed.”

Mr. Holden, summing up his assessment of Mr. Trump’s recollection, said: “I just think he makes things up. That’s what I think. He never thought anybody’s going to check.”

Mr. Trump told the story about nearly dying in a helicopter crash with Mr. Brown after a reporter at Thursday’s news conference asked him a leading question about Vice President Kamala Harris’s long-ago relationship with Mr. Brown and whether it helped her career trajectory.

The two dated in 1994 and 1995 when she was a prosecutor in Alameda County, which includes Oakland, and Mr. Brown was the Assembly speaker. Mr. Brown appointed Ms. Harris to two state boards before she ended their relationship.

“Well, I know Willie Brown very well,” Mr. Trump responded. “In fact, I went down in a helicopter with him.”

He recounted how the two had a close brush with death — “We thought maybe this was the end” — and that Mr. Brown used the frightening ride to tell him “terrible things” about Ms. Harris. “He was not fan of hers very much, at that point,” Mr. Trump said.

Mr. Trump had previously told the story, saying it was Mr. Brown on a helicopter with him, in his book, “Letters to Trump,” which was published in 2023.

Reached again Friday night, Mr. Brown reiterated that he had never flown in a helicopter with Mr. Trump and that he had not denigrated Ms. Harris to the former president because he admires and respects her.

“Those are the two things I am certain of,” he said. “All the rest of this is amusing.”

Asked if Mr. Trump might have confused the two California politicians because they are both Black, Mr. Brown said, “I wouldn’t want to conclude that he can’t tell Black people apart, because I’d hate for him to think that I’m Beyoncé.”

And then he burst out laughing.

Advertisement

Simon J. Levien

People are filing out of the stands at Trump’s rally in Bozeman. He took the stage about 90 minutes after he was originally scheduled to speak after his plane had to land in a different city, and he spoke for about 90 minutes.

Michael Gold

Trump acknowledged that he came to Montana to help boost Republicans’ chances of ousting Senator Jon Tester, the Democratic incumbent. After repeatedly mocking Tester’s weight, he complimented the Republican candidate, Tim Sheehy, over his military service and business acumen. Then, he briefly ceded the stage to Sheehy.

As he continued to try to paint Harris as too liberal for America, Trump stopped his own speech about 40 minutes in to play a video of a number of Harris’s past remarks during her 2020 campaign, when she backed gun buybacks and banning fracking. Harris has moved away from some of the positions she took during her failed presidential bid as she runs now.

And in another unusual interruption, Trump paused his speech with another video, this time a montage of clips from speeches and interviews by Harris that were meant to mock her intelligence and her ability to speak off the cuff.

Trump’s rally in Montana is his first since Kamala Harris chose Gov. Tim Walz of Minnesota as her running mate, and he’s now attacking Walz as overly liberal. He accused Walz of defending socialism, being too lax in his response when protests turned to riots in Minneapolis after the police murder of George Floyd and for being too liberal on issues pertaining to transgender children.

“He ordered tampons in boys’ bathrooms,” Trump said about Walz. “This is her ideology; that’s why she picked him.” While Walz was governor, Minnesota passed a law ordering free menstrual products to be available in public schools for grades 4 through 12. The law Walz signed did not specify putting tampons in boys’ bathrooms, just that schools make tampons available to those who need them.

Trump seemed to acknowledge that his own running mate, Senator JD Vance of Ohio, had a rough start on the trail as old comments he made were unearthed. “He’s got his sea legs now,” Trump insisted at his rally in Bozeman. “He’s going to be great.”

“We’re going back to Butler,” Trump said after talking about the attempt on his life in Butler, Pa., a story that he tells at nearly every rally now, despite saying somberly in his convention speech last month that he would only discuss it that once . He previously announced on his social media site that he would hold a second rally in Butler in part to honor Corey Comperatore, who attended the rally and was shot and killed . His campaign has not announced a date.

Trump just repeated at the Bozeman rally a claim he made on Truth Social previously that Biden would somehow “make a comeback” at the Democratic National Convention and try to take back the nomination. There’s no evidence to support this, and Kamala Harris has already secured the party’s presidential nomination in a virtual roll call of delegates.

Trump has mispronounced Kamala Harris’s name quite a bit in the last few weeks, and in Bozeman, he said he “couldn’t care less” how you say it. Then, he admitted that he has in the past “done a lot of bad name-calling” where he has purposefully mispronounced somebody’s name. “They say, ‘Sir, you made a mistake.’ I said, ‘No, I didn’t.’”

Donald Trump, perhaps flicking at his travel woes earlier after his plane suffered a mechanical issue and was diverted to another city, reflected on how long it takes to travel to Montana. “I’ve got to like Tim Sheehy a lot to be here,” he said. Then, he pledged that Republicans would defeat Senator Jon Tester, the Democratic incumbent, in November, as well as Kamala Harris.

A large screen display at Trump’s rally in Bozeman features a news headline declaring Harris as the first Indian-American senator. This is true. But this display alludes to Trump’s comments last week at a conference for Black journalists when he said Harris “became a Black person” only recently for political advantage. Harris, whose mother was Indian American and whose father is Black, and who attended the historically Black Howard University, has always identified as a Black woman.

Tim Sheehy, the Republican candidate for Senate in Montana, opened his remarks at Trump’s rally in Bozeman by referring derisively to gender pronouns and to transgender athletes, a culture-war issue that fires up Republican voters. Then, Sheehy, a former Navy SEAL, touted his record as a veteran, which drew cheers from a crowded arena.

He then tried to tie his Democratic opponent, Senator Jon Tester of Montana, to Vice President Kamala Harris, accusing both of them of voting against America’s interests.

These opening lines from Sheehy have become tried and true with Republican audiences. He opened his speech at the national convention in Milwaukee last month with similar words.

Kellen Browning

Kellen Browning and Shane Goldmacher

Harris rides momentum to Arizona, for what her campaign says is largest rally yet.

Vice President Kamala Harris rolled into Arizona on Friday evening with the same political momentum that has infused her first swing across the country this week, drawing a crowd that her campaign estimated at more than 15,000 — her largest yet — in a Western state that not long ago appeared to be falling off the battleground map.

Along with her newly minted running mate, Gov. Tim Walz of Minnesota, Ms. Harris delivered a stump speech that is barely a week old, and yet familiar enough to an impassioned new following that some shouted her lines before she did.

The rally was her fourth in four days with an arena-filling crowd that demonstrated the degree to which her candidacy replacing President Biden’s had remade the 2024 race.

Mr. Walz relished the crowd that filed into the Desert Diamond Arena in Glendale, Ariz., in 100-degree heat as he poked fun at Mr. Trump’s obsession with rally crowds.

“It’s not as if anybody cares about crowd sizes or anything,” Mr. Walz said to knowing cheers.

Despite her momentum, Ms. Harris faces an uphill battle in Arizona , a longtime Republican stronghold that flipped to Mr. Biden in 2020 but, according to polling, had been drifting back to former President Donald J. Trump this year.

To win, she will need to reunite the diverse coalition of voters who delivered the state four years ago, and she made an explicit appeal to one part of that group on Friday: Native American voters.

“As president, I will tell you, I will always honor tribal sovereignty and respect tribal self-determination,” she said. The first speaker at the rally, notably, was Stephen Roe Lewis, the governor of the Gila River Indian Community, south of Phoenix.

In her speech, Ms. Harris zeroed in on two issues that are especially pertinent to Arizonans: immigration and abortion.

Crossings from Mexico into Arizona have remained high this year even as they have dropped elsewhere, and Ms. Harris positioned herself as supporting both an “earned pathway to citizenship” and tougher border restrictions, pointing to her record as California’s attorney general.

“I went after the transnational gangs, the drug cartels and the human traffickers,” Ms. Harris said. “I prosecuted them in case after case, and I won. So I know what I’m talking about.”

By contrast, Ms. Harris said, Mr. Trump was playing politics with the issue. She highlighted his opposition to a bipartisan bill this year that would have beefed up border security.

“He talks a big game about border security,” she said, “but he does not walk the walk.”

The comments come as her campaign began to air a tough-on-immigration ad that labeled her a “border-state prosecutor.” Senior Trump campaign officials see the border and immigration as one of Ms. Harris’s deepest areas of vulnerability, and his campaign has repeatedly labeled her, inaccurately , as Mr. Biden’s failed “border czar.”

Ms. Harris did add a new riff to her speech, responding to Mr. Trump’s muddled comments on Thursday at a news conference in Florida, in which he did not rule out directing the Food and Drug Administration to revoke access to abortion pills.

Ms. Harris said Mr. Trump’s agenda “would ban medication abortion in every state,” adding, “But we are not going to let that happen — because we trust women.”

Mr. Trump has previously supported the Supreme Court’s ruling on the abortion drug mifepristone. Karoline Leavitt, a Trump spokeswoman, said in a statement the former president’s position on mifepristone “remains the same — the Supreme Court unanimously decided on the issue and the matter is settled.”

The abortion rhetoric could prove especially potent in Arizona, where the State Supreme Court reinstated a near-total ban on the procedure this year. The State Legislature eventually repealed it, but abortion is still banned after 15 weeks, and voters will have a chance to enshrine the right to an abortion until fetal viability in the state’s Constitution through a ballot measure in November.

The speakers who preceded Ms. Harris on Friday made a number of appeals to independents and moderate Republicans, another segment she will need to win over.

“I do not recognize my party,” said John Giles, the mayor of Mesa, Ariz., who is a prominent Republican backing Ms. Harris. “We need to elect a ticket who will be the adults in the room.”

Senator Mark Kelly, the Arizona Democrat who is also a Navy veteran and former astronaut, introduced Ms. Harris and Mr. Walz. It was the second time this week that a finalist in Ms. Harris’s running-mate sweepstakes introduced her at a rally. Gov. Josh Shapiro of Pennsylvania did the same in Philadelphia on Tuesday.

Mr. Kelly said Mr. Trump had “zero respect for any of us who have worn the uniform.” Mr. Trump’s allies have raised questions about Mr. Walz’s decision to leave the National Guard in 2005 to run for Congress.

Attendees and speakers said the enormous crowd braving scorching desert temperatures on Friday was a sign that, after months of dreariness among Democrats, momentum in Arizona was finally on their side.

“It may be a little warm outside,” Kate Gallego, the mayor of Phoenix, said, “but based on the energy in this arena, I know it’s Donald Trump who’s feeling the heat.”

Harris has been holding rallies with thousands of attendees this week. At Trump’s rally in Montana this evening — his first since the Democratic ticket was solidified — the venue, which can seat more than 8,000 people, is nearly full. Montana is friendly territory for the former president; it is a state he won in 2016 and 2020 and is not widely considered a battleground this year.

Even though this is a Trump campaign rally, several of the speakers who have taken the stage in the last hour have made it clear that their focus is as much on Montana’s Senate race as the presidential contest. “I want to welcome you to Jon Tester’s retirement party,” Steve Daines said to a cheering crowd, before pivoting to calling for Trump’s election in November.

Kellen Browning

Harris just wrapped up speaking here in Glendale, ending with what has become a classic call-and-response line. “When we fight,” she began, and the crowd roared back: “We win!”

Shane Goldmacher

In Arizona, where immigration is a top issue and the border a daily reality, Harris is citing her work as California attorney general, saying she went after “transnational gangs” and “drug traffickers.” This is a history she did not emphasize in the 2020 Democratic primary. But, as a general election candidate, it is a point of emphasis, including in a new television ad.

Harris is taking the issue of immigration — seen as a political vulnerability for her — head on, saying she supports “strong border security and an earned pathway to citizenship.” She accused Donald Trump of having “no interest or desire to actually fix this problem,” pointing to the fact that he tanked a bipartisan border security deal earlier this year.

Erin Schaff

Erin Schaff

Vice President Kamala Harris and her chief of staff, Sheila Nix, watching her running mate, Gov. Tim Walz of Minnesota, warming up the Glendale, Ariz., crowd from backstage at their rally.

Chris Cameron

Chris Cameron

Walz had said that tonight’s rally in Glendale “might be the largest political gathering in the history of Arizona.” That’s a broad claim to make, and it’s hard to exactly measure, but there have been political gatherings of a similar size in Arizona. Trump claimed in 2017 that 15,000 people turned out for a rally in Phoenix, and a city official said that about 10,000 people were inside the rally with another 4,500 to 5,000 turned away at the door. The Harris campaign estimated that more than 15,000 people are at this rally in Glendale.

Senator Steve Daines of Montana, the leader of the National Republican Senatorial Committee, told reporters that he thought Gov. Tim Walz of Minnesota was the best choice Kamala Harris could have made for a running mate from the perspective of the battle to control the Senate. While he thought that Senator Mark Kelly of Arizona and Gov. Josh Shapiro of Pennsylvania would have helped Democratic Senate candidates in those states, Walz, he said, would not provide such a boost anywhere on the map.

Harris makes an explicit appeal to a crucial part of the Democratic coalition in Arizona: Native American voters. “As president, I will tell you, I will always honor tribal sovereignty and respect tribal self-determination,” she said.

Reid J. Epstein

Reid J. Epstein

Harris, in a bit of local policy for Arizona’s large Native American population, said that as president she would respect tribal self-determination. “I know we have a number of Native leaders, and as president, I will tell you, I will always honor tribal sovereignty and respect tribal self-determination and fight for a future where every Native person can realize their aspirations,” she said.

Harris, interrupted by pro-Palestinian and anti-Gaza war protesters, addresses them directly: “I have been clear, now is the time to get a cease-fire deal,” she says.

Vice President Kamala Harris, now onstage, is complimenting Senator Mark Kelly, who was a finalist that she passed over to be her running mate. “I am so grateful, Mark, for your friendship and your leadership,” she said.

Walz's defense of I.V.F. and of the freedom to make reproductive health care decisions, peppered throughout his speech, could hit particularly hard in Arizona, where the State Supreme Court reinstated an 1864 near-total ban on abortion this spring. It was eventually repealed by the State Legislature, but there is still a 15-week ban on the books.

Walz called the prospect of electing Ruben Gallego to the Senate a “twofer,” because of who would not be elected instead: a reference to Gallego’s Republican opponent, Kari Lake. The lines criticizing Lake, a Republican who is enormously unpopular among Democrats — and some members of her own party — have gotten some of the biggest applause so far.

The crowd begins chanting “lock him up!” as Walz talks about Donald Trump, but he quickly counters: “Better yet, beat the hell out of him at the ballot box.”

The Harris-Walz ticket is less than a week old and already the crowd feels primed for some of the familiar lines from Walz’s speech. They were waiting for the word “joy” and exploded when it came.

Maggie Haberman

Maggie Haberman

Trump claims he has helicopter trip records and threatens to sue.

Former President Donald J. Trump on Friday afternoon vehemently maintained that he had once been in a dangerous helicopter landing with Willie Brown , the former mayor of San Francisco, and insisted he had records to prove it, despite Mr. Brown’s denial.

In an angry phone call to a New York Times reporter as he landed several hours away from his planned rally in Bozeman, Mont., because of a mechanical issue on his plane, Mr. Trump excoriated The Times for its coverage of his meandering news conference on Thursday at Mar-a-Lago, his private club and home, during which he told of an emergency landing during a helicopter trip that he said both he and Mr. Brown had made together.

Mr. Trump was expected to keep his rally schedule on Friday as planned, boarding a smaller plane to complete the journey.

Mr. Brown denied on Thursday that he had ever flown in a helicopter with Mr. Trump.

It appeared Mr. Trump may have confused Willie Brown with Jerry Brown, the former governor of California, with whom Mr. Trump traveled by helicopter in 2018 while surveying wildfire damage in the state. But Jerry Brown, who left office in January 2019, said through a spokesman, “There was no emergency landing and no discussion of Kamala Harris.”

Willie Brown, who was a boyfriend of Vice President Kamala Harris during the 1990s, knew Mr. Trump as a potential business associate during those years, when Mr. Trump, then a New York developer, was working on new projects. A biography of Ms. Harris, “Kamala’s Way: An American Life,” reported that Mr. Trump had sent his private plane for Mr. Brown and Ms. Harris in 1994 to fly them from Boston to New York City.

“We have the flight records of the helicopter,” Mr. Trump insisted Friday, saying the helicopter had landed “in a field,” and indicating that he intended to release the flight records, before shouting that he was “probably going to sue” over the Times article.

When asked to produce the flight records, Mr. Trump responded mockingly, repeating the request in a sing-song voice. As of early Friday evening, he had not provided them.

Mr. Trump has a history of claiming he will provide evidence to back up his claims but ultimately not doing so.

He has also told the helicopter story before, in his 2023 book, “Letters to Trump,” in which he published letters to him from a number of people, including Mr. Brown. In the book, Mr. Trump wrote, “We actually had an emergency landing in a helicopter together. It was a little scary for both of us, but thankfully we made it.”

Neil Vigdor

Neil Vigdor

Two rivals in Michigan’s crucial Senate contest say they were both swatted.

The two leading contenders for Michigan’s open Senate seat disclosed that they had been targeted in separate “swatting” incidents in a span of less than 24 hours, just days after winning primaries in a crucial contest that could determine which party controls the chamber.

The first incident, involving Representative Elissa Slotkin, a Democrat, happened on Thursday night at her home in Oakland County, north of Detroit. The second one occurred on Friday at an address that had been listed on public records under the name of Mike Rogers, the Republican candidate and former House member, in neighboring Livingston County.

Politicians on both sides of the political aisle have increasingly been the target of swatting in recent years. The hoaxes — when false threats are deliberately made to law enforcement to draw a heavily armed response to a person’s home — have added to a climate of intimidation and the harassment of public officials.

Ms. Slotkin was not home at the time of the incident, according to a spokeswoman for her office, Lynsey Mukomel, who said in a statement that Michigan State Police troopers went to the residence after a false threat was emailed to a local official. She did not elaborate on the nature of the false threat. Michigan State Police confirmed they responded.

“Michigan State Police checked the property and confirmed no one was in danger,” Ms. Mukomel said, adding that U.S. Capitol Police would investigate the incident.

Mr. Rogers, a former longtime House member who was endorsed by former President Donald J. Trump, experienced a similar incident around 12:30 p.m. Eastern time on Friday, said Chris Gustafson, a spokesman for his campaign.

A person reported that a man was holding a woman at gunpoint at the property in Livingston County connected with Mr. Rogers, according to Mr. Gustafson, who said that Mr. Rogers currently does not live there but that other members of his family do. (Mr. Rogers now lives in Oakland County, Mich., according to his campaign.)

Shanon Banner, a Michigan State Police spokeswoman, said that a sergeant had responded to a report about a domestic situation at a residence in Livingston County on Friday and determined that it was false. She was not immediately able to confirm whether it was the same property.

Mr. Gustafson, in a statement, said that it was the second time that Mr. Rogers had been targeted in a swatting incident. The first was in 2013, when he was a member of Congress.

“This kind of violence cannot be tolerated, and it is our hope that those responsible will be quickly prosecuted and held accountable,” Mr. Gustafson said.

The rivals are running for a seat that is being vacated by Senator Debbie Stabenow, Michigan’s senior senator and a Democrat, who announced last year that she would not seek a fifth term . Democrats control the Senate by a thin 51-49 seat majority.

Ken Bensinger

Ken Bensinger

Joe Rogan would like to clarify: He did not endorse Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

The world’s most popular podcaster has, sort of, but not really, thrown his support to one of the 2024 presidential race’s least popular candidates.

On Thursday, Joe Rogan said he preferred Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who is running as an independent, for president. “He’s the only one that makes sense to me,” Mr. Rogan said, as a guest on a podcast hosted by Lex Fridman, and called Mr. Kennedy a “legitimate guy.”

Mr. Rogan’s devoted following, one that leans young, male and numbers in the tens of millions, is highly coveted. His remarks about Mr. Kennedy, uttered on a show with a far smaller reach than his own, nonetheless set off a frenzied response.

Supporters of former President Donald J. Trump, worried that Mr. Rogan’s stance could carve off voters and hurt his electoral chances come November, quickly turned on the podcaster, standup comic and U.F.C. announcer. They questioned his intelligence and even mocked his height , a spectacle that was greeted with something akin to joy — or, at least, schadenfreude — among Democrats who have long written off Mr. Rogan as helpful to their cause.

By Friday morning, Mr. Rogan was backpedaling. “This isn’t an endorsement,” he posted on the social media platform X, and advised that he is “not the guy to get political information from.”

Mr. Trump himself weighed in on Friday afternoon, pondering “how loudly Joe Rogan gets BOOED the next time he enters the UFC ring” in a post on his social network that seemingly reflected his concerns that the influential podcaster could tip the scales against him.

“This takes straight from the Trump base,” said Mike Madrid, a Republican political consultant. A New York Times/Siena poll in battleground states in May found that 54 percent of respondents who said they planned to vote for the former president had a favorable opinion of Mr. Rogan.

Mr. Kennedy, long before Mr. Rogan’s unwinding act, had already taken credit for the perceived nod, posting on social media: “From one ‘legitimate’ guy to another, thank you.”

Even if it’s not a true endorsement, Mr. Rogan’s praise could come as a huge shot in the arm for Mr. Kennedy, who has seen his polling average drop from as much as 15 percent in early June to somewhere around 6 percent as of late last month.

While Mr. Kennedy drew national attention this week after acknowledging that he dumped a dead bear cub in Central Park a decade ago, such headlines have not helped ease his struggles raising money . He’s also fighting to get his name on the ballots in critical states, or, in the case of New York , keep it there.

“He doesn’t attack people. He attacks actions and ideas, but he’s much more reasonable and intelligent,” Mr. Rogan said of Mr. Kennedy on the “Lex Fridman Podcast,” which has 4.1 million subscribers on YouTube.

Mr. Rogan’s fan base is much bigger. In March, Spotify said that “The Joe Rogan Experience” had 14.5 million followers , almost triple the platform’s second most popular program. He also has 19 million followers on Instagram and 17 million followers on YouTube.

A poll by YouGov last year found that 81 percent of his listeners are male and 56 percent are under 35 years old , feeding the perception that he has a direct line to a cohort that polling suggests tends to support Mr. Trump over Vice President Kamala Harris.

“This is a group Trump needs strong performance with,” Mr. Madrid said.

During his interview with Mr. Fridman, he said that he was “not a Trump supporter in any way, shape or form” and adding that he turned down multiple offers to have him on his show. “I’ve said no every time,” Mr. Rogan said. “I’m not interested in helping him,”

Mr. Kennedy sat for an interview on the “Joe Rogan Experience” in June 2023.

Ruth Igielnik contributed reporting.

Jazmine Ulloa

Jazmine Ulloa

Reporting from Washington

A Latino rights group breaks with its history to endorse the Harris-Walz ticket.

The League of United Latin American Citizens, one of the nation’s oldest Latino civil rights organizations, said on Friday that it supported Vice President Kamala Harris and her running mate, Gov. Tim Walz of Minnesota, the first formal endorsement of a presidential ticket in the group’s 95-year history.

Leaders of the group, known as LULAC, acknowledged that it had previously refrained from endorsing political candidates but said that members were stirred to action by concerns over the potential negative impact on Latinos if former President Donald J. Trump were elected again.

The endorsement was carried out through the group’s political action committee, the LULAC Adelante PAC, after internal conversations and a unanimous vote. Leaders said they decided to endorse Ms. Harris and Mr. Walz because they were better equipped to address the issues facing Latino communities.

“We can trust them to do what is right for our community and the country,” Domingo Garcia, the chairman of the PAC and a past LULAC president, said in a statement.

Latinos, a multiracial and multiethnic slice of the electorate that made up 10 percent of American voters in 2020, tend to vote Democratic.

But they have been at the center of a tug of war between Democrats and Republicans since Mr. Trump improved his standing with Latinos in 2020 compared with his 2016 campaign. As Mr. Trump and President Biden appeared to be headed for a rematch in the 2024 presidential election, a significant number of Latinos had been considering a third-party option .

Latino rights leaders and elected officials have quickly coalesced behind Ms. Harris since she replaced Mr. Biden at the top of the ticket. They said Mr. Trump’s pledges to cut low-income assistance programs and enact hard-line immigration policies would hurt Latino communities across the country.

Leaders of LULAC and similar groups said Ms. Harris’s candidacy had shot new energy into their outreach efforts. Some early polling has captured higher enthusiasm for her than Mr. Biden among Latino voters, but reliable data since the switch is limited.

LULAC, founded in South Texas by a group of mostly Mexican American veterans of World War I, has traditionally taken more conservative stances than other Latino rights groups. Its endorsement will allow its councils, which function as local chapters, to register voters and knock on doors in battleground states, particularly Nevada, Arizona, Georgia, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. The organization has 535 councils nationwide and 140,000 members, 86 percent of whom are registered to vote and more than 75 percent of whom voted in the 2020 election, its officials said.

In a statement, Julie Chavez Rodriguez, Ms. Harris’s campaign manager, called the endorsement an honor. “The stakes of this election require Latinos to unify and organize together like our lives depend on it,” she said.

The Trump campaign said that the LULAC endorsement came as no surprise. In a statement, Jaime Florez, the campaign’s Latino media director, argued such groups were out of touch with Latino voters, saying their lack of interest in what matters to Latinos had caused many to leave the party behind.

Until now, the closest LULAC had come to endorsing a presidential candidate was in 1956, when Felix Tijerina, then the group’s president, personally backed the Eisenhower-Nixon ticket. He wore an Ike pin on his lapel, according to news coverage from that time. Some members of the group were also active in clubs boosting John F. Kennedy in 1960, and others have supported local candidates, including Raymond Telles, the former mayor of El Paso.

Mr. Trump now points to the Eisenhower administration’s mass deportations of Mexicans and Mexican Americans as a model that his own administration would follow as he promises to undertake the largest deportation effort in U.S. history.

In an interview, Juan Proaño, LULAC’s chief executive, said the group’s values had evolved since the 1960s, when fierce wage competition and divisions between Mexican and Mexican American laborers initially put the Latino rights group in favor of Eisenhower’s mass deportations. The organization reversed its stance when it was no longer possible to ignore the devastation that the deportations inflicted on Mexican American neighborhoods and border regions.

Ahead of its endorsement, LULAC released an analysis of Mr. Trump’s promises. It cited a range of his proposals that would hurt Latinos, including cuts to education budgets and social safety net programs, and policies that would shut down the border, undo birthright citizenship and roll back protections for young people brought into the country illegally as children.

“We can’t risk mass deportations, we can’t risk family separations,” Mr. Proaño said.

Tim Walz’s class project on the Holocaust is drawing new attention online.

The prediction was spot on: Rwanda was barreling toward a devastating genocide.

It did not emanate from a think tank, but from a high school geography class in western Nebraska. The year was 1993. The teacher? Tim Walz, now the Democratic vice-presidential candidate and Minnesota governor.

Thirty-one years later, the class project is drawing new attention. Mr. Walz, a geography teacher at the time, had asked his students to take what they had learned about the Holocaust to predict which nation was most at risk for genocide.

“They came up with Rwanda,” Mr. Walz said, talking about the project at a conference last month . “Twelve months later, the world witnessed the horrific genocide in Rwanda.”

The project was reported on in a 2008 On Education column for The New York Times that has been widely shared in recent days. Mr. Walz had drawn the attention of the reporter, Samuel G. Freedman, for an earlier column because Mr. Walz was the only K-12 teacher serving in Congress at the time, Mr. Freedman said.

“While I was interviewing Walz for the initial column, he told me how the genocide project was one of his proudest moments as an educator,” said Mr. Freedman, who is now a journalism professor at Columbia University . That sparked Mr. Freedman to revisit the story later.

Mr. Walz, when he delivered the lesson plan, had been teaching global geography in Alliance, Neb., and had been chosen for a Belfer fellowship to the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum that was opening. Speaking at the conference last month, held by Esri, a company that makes G.I.S. software widely used in mapping, he said the project had a profound effect on his students and bred some cynicism.

“How could a bunch of students in western Nebraska, in Alliance, use a computer program and some past historical knowledge to come up with this?” he said. “Why was nobody doing anything about that?”

Several years later, when he was studying for his master’s degree in experiential education at Minnesota State University, Mankato, Mr. Walz wrote his thesis on Holocaust education, the Jewish Telegraphic Agency reported .

As governor, Mr. Walz signed a bill last year that requires high schools and middle schools to teach about the Holocaust, along with other genocides.

IMAGES

  1. Once More To The Lake, By E.B White Summary And Thesis Essay

    thesis for once more to the lake

  2. Precis: Once More to the Lake Essay Example

    thesis for once more to the lake

  3. E.B. White's "Once More to the Lake" paragraph analysis

    thesis for once more to the lake

  4. Once More To The Lake, By E.B White Summary And Thesis Essay

    thesis for once more to the lake

  5. Once More to the Lake by E

    thesis for once more to the lake

  6. Once More To The Lake Analysis Essay Example

    thesis for once more to the lake

COMMENTS

  1. What is a good thesis statement for "One More to the Lake"?

    Expert Answers. The Greek philosopher Heraclitus is supposed to have said that no one ever steps into the same river twice: the second time, it is not the same river and he is not the same man ...

  2. What Is the Thesis of "Once More to the Lake" by E.B. White?

    "Once More to the Lake" is an essay by E.B. White describing his emotions when he returns to a childhood summer place. He had first visited the Maine camp with his own father in 1904, and he revisits in 1941 with his son. He compares the lake of his memory with the largely unchanged contemporary scene and simultaneously experiences the place through his son's eyes and his own.

  3. Analysis of E. B. White's "Once More to the Lake"

    E.B. White's essay, Once More to the Lake, which was first published in 1941, describes his experience as he revisits a childhood lake in Maine. This revisiting is a journey in which White delights in memories associated with his childhood and the lake. In effect, his mindset transforms and goes back to his childhood.

  4. PDF Once More to the Lake by E. B. White

    by E. B. White. E. B. White (1898 - 1985) began his career as a professional writer with the newly founded New Yorker magazine in the 1920s. Over the years he produced nineteen books, including collections of essays, the famous children's books Stuart Little and Charlotte's Web, and the long popular writing textbook The Elements of Style.

  5. Once More to the Lake Summary and Study Guide

    Summary: "Once More to the Lake". "Once More to the Lake" is a narrative non-fiction essay written by E.B. White. The essay was originally published in Harper's Magazine in 1941. White (1899-1985) was an American author best known for his children's novels, including Charlotte's Web and Stuart Little, as well as his contribution ...

  6. Once More to the Lake Summary & Analysis

    Summary of Once More to the Lake by E.B. White. "Once More to the Lake" is one of White's most acclaimed essays by E.B. White. Published in 1941, it is a deeply personal and reflective piece that explores the theme of the passage of time and the cyclical nature of life. The essay recounts White's visit to a lake in Maine, where he had ...

  7. Once More to the Lake Essay Analysis

    Analysis: "Once More to the Lake". Although the scope of White's narrative is rather narrow as he recounts a summer vacation with his son, he employs the trip as a framing narrative that supports a complex commentary regarding the passage of time. Throughout the essay, White attempts to balance the sensation of timelessness he experiences ...

  8. Once More to the Lake

    Once More to the Lake" is an essay first published in Harper's Magazine in 1941 by author E. B. White. ... Once More to the Lake. Essays of E.B White. New York: Harper & Row, 1977. 197-202. This page was last edited on 21 January 2023, at 11:33 (UTC). Text is available under the ...

  9. Once More to the Lake by E.B. White

    E.B. White's "Once More to the Lake" literary non-fictional essay is rich in sensory detail that tingles the reader's five senses. When this essay is told in a non-linear format, this essay ...

  10. What is White's argument in "Once More to the Lake"?

    E.B. White's essay "Once More to the Lake" presents an argument for the perpetuation of the cycle of life. As White travels with his son to the lake where he spent his childhood vacations ...

  11. 'Pattern of Life Indelible': E.b. White'S 'Once More to The Lake'

    E.B. WHITE'S "ONCE MORE TO THE LAKE" Describing his craft, E.B. White wrote in 1964 to Scott Elledge: "I was interested in your remarks about the writer as poser, because, of course, all writing is both a mask and an unveiling, particularly in the case of the essayist, who must take his trousers off without showing his genitals.

  12. E.B. White's Drafts of 'Once More to the Lake'

    Every August for the past decade, White's father had taken the family to the same camp on Belgrade Lake in Maine. In a self-designed pamphlet, complete with sketches and photos, young Elwyn began his report clearly and conventionally. This wonderful lake is five miles wide, and about ten miles long, with many coves, points and islands.

  13. What is the dominant impression and main idea of "Once More To The Lake

    Adding to these impressions is the role of technology, the eroding nature of memory, and the passage of time changing the way White views his past memories of the lake. The main idea of this work ...

  14. Once More to the Lake Themes

    Linear and Cyclical Concepts of Time. "Once More to the Lake" reflects White's efforts to make sense of the passage of time in his own life. Using his nostalgic return to the lake as a framing device, White outlines two competing models of time. Most prominently, he invokes a notion of time based on the cyclical, repetitive nature of ...

  15. Once More to the Lake by E. B. White [Summary of the Essay]

    "Once More to the Lake" is an essay first published in Harper's Magazine in 1941 by author E. B. White. It chronicles his pilgrimage back to a lakefront reso...

  16. What are three changes reflected in E. B. White's "Once More to the

    a thesis statement is a single sentence that tells readers what your paper is about. ... For an essay concerned with change in "Once More to the Lake," the introduction should address how ...

  17. E. B. White's Song of Summer

    White memorialized summer in "Once More to the Lake," a 1941 meditation on the passage of time that has become among the most widely anthologized essays in the English language. Elwyn Brooks White (1899-1985)—Andy to his friends—is best known as the author of Charlotte's Web and Stuart Little , children's books inspired by his ...

  18. Once More to the Lake

    To print or download this file, click the link below: Once More to the Lake EB White (1).pdf — PDF document, 119 KB (122137 bytes)

  19. E. B. White

    Once More to the Lake Lyrics. One summer, along about 1904, my father rented a camp on a lake in Maine and took us all there for the month of August. We all got ringworm from some kittens and had ...

  20. Once More to the Lake Key Figures

    In "Once More to the Lake," White performs an act of extended act of self-examination that features very little interpersonal interaction with other individuals who feature in the essay. Although the essay is set in a bustling campsite and White describes several other people, the descriptions are ultimately reflections of White himself.

  21. Rare catch in Lake Erie called a 'unicorn,' and a fish of a lifetime

    "Once it was netted, as soon as I felt the jaw, saw the jaw, I thought 'OK, this is a coho [salmon],' but as soon as I saw the spots, I was like, 'Oh my gosh, this is an Atlantic salmon ...

  22. E. B. White's essay "Once More to the Lake" explores themes of

    Get an answer for 'E. B. White's essay "Once More to the Lake" explores themes of nostalgia, childhood memories, and the passage of time' and find homework help for other E. B. White questions at ...

  23. Serbian CrossFit competitor Lazar Dukic dies during Texas lake swimming

    A CrossFit Games competitor has died while taking part in a swimming event. Lazar Dukic was competing at Marine Creek Lake in Fort Worth, Texas, on Thursday morning when he disappeared beneath the ...

  24. 2024 Michigan elections: campaign, polls, dates, voter information

    The district has become more conservative since 2020 redistricting. Kildee's district had once been anchored solely by Flint but now stretches north to encompass the more conservative tri-cities region consisting of Midland, Saginaw and Bay City. It means the congressional race is expected to be one of the state's closest.

  25. Does the theme of nostalgia in E.B. White's "Once More to the Lake

    E. B. White's essay "Once More to the Lake" explores themes of nostalgia, childhood memories, and the passage of time What are three changes reflected in E. B. White's "Once More to the Lake"?

  26. Once More to the Lake Literary Devices

    For example, White complains that the outboard motorboats "whined about one's ears like mosquitoes" (4), underscoring the annoyance he feels at their presence. Thanks for exploring this SuperSummary Study Guide of "Once More to the Lake" by E. B. White. A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality ...

  27. Election Highlights: Trump Takes Stage in Montana After Harris and Walz

    He attacks actions and ideas, but he's much more reasonable and intelligent," Mr. Rogan said of Mr. Kennedy on the "Lex Fridman Podcast," which has 4.1 million subscribers on YouTube.